The transaction that gave birth to the Studio Inn in Painesville, Ohio, was less a conventional real-estate sale than an exchange of dreams.
Grace Bond and Dorothy Moodey were operating an inn in Painesville that had been known as “The Tea Kettle” since its opening in 1911. Dorcas and Wendell Oliver, meanwhile, had begun their own improbable career as restaurateurs at the Octagon House—an eight-sided brick landmark just outside town that had been built by a local resident in 1840 as a sort of tribute to Thomas Jefferson. In 1941 Bond and Moodey took over the Octagon House and the Olivers moved to the Tea Kettle, renamed it the Studio Inn, and set about remaking nearly every room by hand.
The stately old house at 102 West Erie Street had been built sometime around 1870 as the family home of Zenuf “Zeke” Wilson. As the Studio Inn, its coach house and domestic arrangement of parlors, hallways, and stairs would give diners the sensation of being received in a private home rather than processed through a commercial dining room.
Dorcas Henderson Oliver brought her own Ohio pedigree to the Studio Inn. She was born and raised in Kenton, and her father was a prominent judge who had been the dean of the law school at Ohio Northern University. She graduated from the School of the Art Institute of Chicago and studied for two years in Paris with George Elmer Browne, an American painter and influential art teacher who in 1916 had founded the West End School of Art in Provincetown, Massachusetts, and regularly conducted classes in Europe. Before returning to Ohio, she worked as a commercial artist in New York City.
Wendell Oliver was likewise trained at the Art Institute of Chicago and spent two years at the Académie Colarossi in Paris. He worked in commercial art and interior decoration in Chicago and New York, traveled in Europe, and developed a serious enthusiasm for culinary exploration. His European travels sharpened both his palate and his confidence in the kitchen.
By their own account, the Olivers had grown tired of metropolitan life. They wanted room to travel, time to paint, and a livelihood that could be arranged around both. Painesville made practical sense to Dorcas: it stood between Chicago and New York, close enough to either city to maintain family ties and professional connections. Their solution was to combine Wendell’s interest in food with their shared command of color, composition, and design. They would make a restaurant that was also a gallery, gift shop, travel diary, and stage set.
They did not arrive in Painesville as experienced innkeepers. At the West Erie Street house they cleaned, papered, painted, decorated, and trimmed, learning restaurant work the hard way. Yet inexperience may have freed them from convention. The Studio Inn did not look like a standardized dining room because the Olivers did not think like professional restaurateurs. They treated the old house as a series of compositions. Rooms acquired names—the Gingham Room, Trellis Hall, and the Blue Grass Room—each with its own decorative character. Plants, handblown glass, antiques, flowered paper, and Mexican objects shared space with an elegant cut-glass chandelier that Wendell had carried home from Paris. Mahogany banisters and the old house’s distinctive architecture remained part of the effect.
The Studio Inn’s name was literal. Art was not an accessory hung after the restaurant had been furnished; it was one of the reasons the restaurant existed. Dorcas and Wendell displayed their own work and made room for other artists. The Blue Grass Gift Shop in the old carriage house became Dorcas’s particular domain; there she mixed paintings, ceramics, and handmade jewelry by Cleveland-area artists with imports from Mexico, France, Italy, Portugal, and Spain. A 1948 advertisement distilled the Olivers’ theatrical salesmanship into a phrase: it was “divine to dine at Studio Inn.”
The couple also understood that a destination restaurant needed a sense of occasion. In 1949 they invited the public to a “Garden Sale of Art,” directed by Cleveland artist Kae Dorn Cass, a gifted watercolorist and longtime member of the faculty of the Cleveland School of Art. The Olivers encouraged clubs and sorority groups to make “a bus-ride for fun to our door.” Visitors could take tea while viewing paintings, then pass into rooms whose furnishings and merchandise blurred the line between restaurant, exhibition, and bazaar. Even Duncan Hines, whose guidebooks could make or break a roadside dining room, came to eat there in 1948 while attending the National Restaurant Association’s convention in Cleveland. The restaurant later advertised his recommendation, a powerful assurance to travelers on Route 20 that the eccentric old house also met his exacting standards of food and service.
The Studio Inn offered a menu as distinctive as its setting. A 1947 food column singled out its “Gorgeous Board,” an Americanized play on the Swedish smörgåsbord. A 1953 listing promised hot sweet rolls and cheese sticks, fresh shrimp, “pampered chicken,” steaks, lobster Newburg, green noodles, fresh vegetables, and rich desserts. Oven-fried chicken became one of the restaurant’s best-known dishes. Luncheon and dinner prices ranged from $1.25 to $3.75, with party meals offering “many extras.”
The Studio Inn was also a popular venue for parties and social gatherings. Its old rooms and layered decorations gave private meals a setting more personal than a hotel banquet room. Advertisements emphasized luncheons, dinners, and parties, “gay music,” candlelight, and air conditioning. The Olivers employed about twenty people at the height of the business, enough to sustain the elaborate service and the labor-intensive dishes that guests remembered.
No aspect of the Studio Inn mattered more to its identity than Mexico. For roughly a decade, the Olivers closed the restaurant around November 1, drove south, and spent about five months painting and traveling before returning to reopen in April. By 1953 they had logged some 75,000 miles on these annual journeys. They worked at their easels in Guadalajara, Taxco, San Miguel de Allende, Cuernavaca, Ajijic, and around Lake Pátzcuaro. Dorcas regarded Pátzcuaro and the island of Janitzio as the most beautiful place on earth and repeatedly painted the region’s Purépecha people, then commonly called Tarascans, in their local dress.
Their winter absences were not escapes from the restaurant so much as part of its production cycle. Mexico supplied paintings, textiles, silver, glass, jewelry, decorative ideas, and stories. Each spring the Studio Inn reopened replenished. In 1950 the couple returned in their yellow Studebaker Starlight two-door coupe stuffed with work from a four-month painting tour below the Rio Grande. A growing tree in the gift shop had been painted shocking pink, its branches hung with Mexican silver bracelets and concho belts.
That Easter, the Studio Inn opened its tenth season with an exhibition devoted to Mexican subjects. Dorcas showed watercolors of Ajijic on Lake Chapala, along with architectural studies, tropical flowers, and fruit; the works were displayed in the Gingham Room and Trellis Hall. Wendell contributed scenes of Cuernavaca’s Borda Gardens, churches at Ajijic, landscapes near Taxco, and views of Lake Chapala. Their work was joined by paintings from Irma René Koen, a Chicago artist who often worked in Cuernavaca, and Frederick Jennison, who had lived for years in Taxco. The exhibition transformed the annual reopening into an art event and made the winter journey visible in every corner of the inn.
The Studio Inn continued to host notable painters. Later in 1950, Kae Dorn Cass exhibited watercolors selected from trips through the American West, Mexico, the Gaspé Peninsula, Nova Scotia, Bermuda, and New England, as well as earlier European travel. Cass had taught at the Cleveland Institute of Art for more than 25 years and had participated repeatedly in the Cleveland Museum of Art’s May Show. Dorcas and Wendell directed the exhibition and received visitors with her. The Blue Grass Gift Room thus functioned not merely as a souvenir shop but as a small regional gallery capable of presenting serious professional work.
The Olivers’ life looked enviably unconventional, but it was governed by discipline. They ran an inn for seven months, closed it, drove thousands of miles, painted intensively, acquired stock, and returned to begin again. Dorcas explained the philosophy behind the schedule: “We have the feeling that people should live as they go along. Why wait until you retire to do the things you want to do? So many people are afraid of the word ‘retire.’ They wouldn’t be if they knew how to try new worlds of experience. To do that makes you more interesting and enthusiastic as you grow older instead of the opposite.”
The arrangement also gave the Studio Inn the rhythm of a summer resort even though it stood on a principal highway in an Ohio county seat. Each reopening could bring new paintings, new imports, and visual surprise. Guests did not simply return for another meal; they came to see what the Olivers had brought back.
In early 1954 the Olivers sold the Studio Inn to Karl Griffith Sasse of Princeton, New Jersey. Sasse, a graduate of the Wharton School of Business and Finance at the University of Pennsylvania and a Navy veteran of World War II, had spent four years as assistant manager of the Nassau Tavern in Princeton.
The Olivers’ departure ended the Studio Inn’s most inventive period, but not the restaurant itself. Under Sasse, who retained the established name, the inn generally operated from May through October, while the gift shop remained open in winter. Sasse’s unexpected death at age 67 in 1968, however, forced the Studio Inn’s closing.
The final transformation of the Studio Inn came quickly. Sasse’s heirs sold the property to Red Barn, Inc., a rapidly expanding fast-food chain founded in Springfield, Ohio, that was known for barn-shaped restaurant buildings as well as its hamburgers and fried chicken. The inn’s contents were sold at auction in October 1968, with buyers carrying away the French chandelier, mahogany banisters, and antique fixtures and furnishings that had made its rooms so distinctive.
In 1969 wrecking crews moved onto 102 West Erie Street. The Studio Inn’s flower-papered walls and timbers were burned; its old bricks went to the yard of a local excavating company. A reporter for a local newspaper who covered the demolition began her story with a wistful recollection of the Studio Inn. “It was,” a former patron recalled, “the finest dining place around.”











